Why does replacing like with like work in Google?
Google tends to reserve slots on page one for each type of result, so a negative result is most likely displaced by a stronger positive result of the same type.
Is a negative result ranking for your name? We remove what can be removed and push down what can’t. Confidential from the first call.
A typical page one for a company mixes result types: the corporate site, news, social profiles, ratings pages, video and encyclopedia entries. Google tries to keep that variety, which means each type competes mainly with others of its kind. A negative social media result is more likely to be pushed down by a stronger, more active social profile than by another news article.
A poor ratings page is more likely to be displaced by a better-established ratings page. Knowing which slot a negative occupies tells you what kind of asset can realistically replace it, and saves months spent building content that was never going to compete for that position.